Skip to main content

Site navigation

  • University of Technology Sydney home
  • Home

    Home
  • For students

  • For industry

  • Research

Explore

  • Courses
  • Events
  • News
  • Stories
  • People

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt
  • Study at UTS

    • arrow_right_alt Find a course
    • arrow_right_alt Course areas
    • arrow_right_alt Undergraduate students
    • arrow_right_alt Postgraduate students
    • arrow_right_alt Research Masters and PhD
    • arrow_right_alt Online study and short courses
  • Student information

    • arrow_right_alt Current students
    • arrow_right_alt New UTS students
    • arrow_right_alt Graduates (Alumni)
    • arrow_right_alt High school students
    • arrow_right_alt Indigenous students
    • arrow_right_alt International students
  • Admissions

    • arrow_right_alt How to apply
    • arrow_right_alt Entry pathways
    • arrow_right_alt Eligibility
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for students

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Apply for a coursearrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt
  • Scholarshipsarrow_right_alt
  • Featured industries

    • arrow_right_alt Agriculture and food
    • arrow_right_alt Defence and space
    • arrow_right_alt Energy and transport
    • arrow_right_alt Government and policy
    • arrow_right_alt Health and medical
    • arrow_right_alt Corporate training
  • Explore

    • arrow_right_alt Tech Central
    • arrow_right_alt Case studies
    • arrow_right_alt Research
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for industry

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Find a UTS expertarrow_right_alt
  • Partner with usarrow_right_alt
  • Explore

    • arrow_right_alt Explore our research
    • arrow_right_alt Research centres and institutes
    • arrow_right_alt Graduate research
    • arrow_right_alt Research partnerships
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for research

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Find a UTS expertarrow_right_alt
  • Research centres and institutesarrow_right_alt
  • University of Technology Sydney home
Explore the University of Technology Sydney
Category Filters:
University of Technology Sydney home University of Technology Sydney home
  1. home
  2. arrow_forward_ios ... Newsroom
  3. arrow_forward_ios ... 2023
  4. arrow_forward_ios 07
  5. arrow_forward_ios The myth of free speech absolutism

The myth of free speech absolutism

18 July 2023
Profile of a face with open mouth, tongue extended, the end of it transformed to birds in flight

Last week, a Louisiana judge ordered Biden administration officials not to email, phone or otherwise contact social media companies about content moderation. But wait, isn’t this an infringement of the officials’ First Amendment right to free speech? Actually, the judge did invoke the First Amendment in his decision. The case had been brought by Republican attorneys-general arguing that the Biden administration’s efforts to crack down on misinformation constituted ‘the most egregious violations of the First Amendment in the history of the United States of America’. And the judge, a Trump appointee, agreed, comparing the US government to Orwell’s Ministry of Truth. There had been ‘a massive effort,’ he wrote, ‘to suppress speech based on its content’.

The First Amendment has been popping up a lot in US cases. Late last month, the US Supreme Court held that a Colorado website designer could refuse to build a site for a gay couple named Stewart and Mike thanks to the designer’s First Amendment rights. The decision sets a hugely significant precedent, but it wasn’t unanimous. In her withering dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote, ‘Today, the Court, for the first time in its history, grants a business open to the public a constitutional right to refuse to serve members of a protected class.’ The curious postscript, revealed by good if belated journalism, was that there was in fact no gay couple who had sought the website designer’s services. ‘Stewart and Mike’ were a fiction. The decision purportedly in support of free speech was based on a fabricated claim.

Free speech is more slippery than a slip-n-slide. The concept seems simple. The authors of US democracy thought it so important that they enshrined it in the First Amendment of their Constitution. In reality, however, it’s tricky. The right to free speech needs to be balanced against other rights and obligations, such as the right to privacy, the right not to be defamed, and prohibitions on illegal speech, such as live-streaming a massacre. In Australia, the situation is even trickier because free speech is barely protected under the law, with the exception of the implied freedom of political communication that the High Court has inferred from the Constitution. That’s the same implied freedom Pauline Hanson is invoking to defend herself against Mehreen Faruqi’s defamation action, by arguing that section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act – making it unlawful to offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate someone because of their race or ethnicity – is unconstitutional.

In Australia, the legal and regulatory mechanisms to protect free speech, and to give guidance about what speech is unacceptable, are inadequate and inconsistent. Platform policies are worse. The result is a public sphere that’s a mess. ‘GOODBYE,’ tweeted Sam Neill on July 3. ‘My friends, I’m just going to walk quietly away ... I am not happy with what’s happened at Twitter & I’m not happy to be in a place that is so angry & divisive.’ This followed Stan Grant’s retreat from public life following sustained online attacks. Cleaning up the mess requires a delicate combination of high-level principles coupled with more granular responses, as the CMT recently argued in a submission to UNESCO. The solution also ought to involve a more coherent professional standards scheme for journalists that also encompasses content on digital platforms. Otherwise, the bellowers and bullies will continue to drive out people with genuinely original and valuable contributions.

Sacha Molitorisz

Sacha Molitorisz, Senior Lecturer - UTS Law

 

This article was featured in our fortnightly newsletter - read it in full here or subscribe!

Share
Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter Share this on LinkedIn
Back to CMT news

Acknowledgement of Country

UTS acknowledges the Gadigal People of the Eora Nation and the Boorooberongal People of the Dharug Nation upon whose ancestral lands our campuses now stand. We would also like to pay respect to the Elders both past and present, acknowledging them as the traditional custodians of knowledge for these lands. 

University of Technology Sydney

City Campus

15 Broadway, Ultimo, NSW 2007

Get in touch with UTS

Follow us

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Facebook

A member of

  • Australian Technology Network
Use arrow keys to navigate within each column of links. Press Tab to move between columns.

Study

  • Find a course
  • Undergraduate
  • Postgraduate
  • How to apply
  • Scholarships and prizes
  • International students
  • Campus maps
  • Accommodation

Engage

  • Find an expert
  • Industry
  • News
  • Events
  • Experience UTS
  • Research
  • Stories
  • Alumni

About

  • Who we are
  • Faculties
  • Learning and teaching
  • Sustainability
  • Initiatives
  • Equity, diversity and inclusion
  • Campus and locations
  • Awards and rankings
  • UTS governance

Staff and students

  • Current students
  • Help and support
  • Library
  • Policies
  • StaffConnect
  • Working at UTS
  • UTS Handbook
  • Contact us
  • Copyright © 2025
  • ABN: 77 257 686 961
  • CRICOS provider number: 00099F
  • TEQSA provider number: PRV12060
  • TEQSA category: Australian University
  • Privacy
  • Copyright
  • Disclaimer
  • Accessibility