- Posted on 16 Nov 2026
- 5-minute read
New research challenges assumptions about the financial risks of the energy transition and offers important lessons for policymakers, companies and investors.
The global shift towards cleaner energy raises a difficult financial question: are fossil-fuel companies worth more than they should be because investors have not fully accounted for the risks of climate change and stronger climate policies?
This is the concern behind the so-called carbon bubble. If governments introduce stronger climate policies, or demand for coal, oil and gas declines as cleaner energy becomes more competitive, some fossil-fuel reserves and infrastructure could lose value. Companies could face falling revenues, investors could suffer losses, and financial institutions could be exposed to risks they have not adequately anticipated.
But how large is this potential financial risk? And are financial markets already taking climate policy into account when valuing fossil-fuel companies?
Researchers at the Centre for Climate Risk and Resilience at UTS Business School with colleagues from Macquarie University have examined these questions by investigating how major climate policy developments affect the market value of leading US-listed fossil-fuel companies.
The research examines 31 major climate policy signals between 1996 and 2023. These include 27 United Nations climate conferences (COP meetings) and four significant policy announcements in the United States and European Union. Using information from stock and options markets, the researchers estimate company valuations under two scenarios, namely one based on business as usual, without additional climate-policy constraints, and another that accounts for climate-related policy risks. The difference between the two provides an estimate of the potential carbon bubble.
The findings offer a different perspective on a debate that has often focused on the possibility of substantial losses across the fossil-fuel sector. The estimated carbon bubble represents approximately 5.5% of the current market value of the largest US-listed fossil-fuel companies with traded options. This is equivalent to around US$99.3 billion. The results suggest that financial markets have already incorporated some of the risks associated with climate policy into company valuations. While these risks are real, the estimated potential overvaluation is considerably smaller than some previous estimates have suggested.
In other words, the research does not point to an inevitable collapse in the value of fossil-fuel companies. Instead, it suggests that markets may be adjusting to the energy transition more gradually, with the extent of financial exposure depending partly on how companies respond to changing policy and market conditions.
Rethinking the Carbon Bubble
The findings challenge the assumption that stronger climate policies must automatically lead to substantial financial losses for every fossil-fuel company. Companies are not all equally exposed to the energy transition. Their financial position can depend on the quality of their assets, their investment decisions, their ability to adapt and how effectively they prepare for a changing energy market.
This is an important distinction. A company that recognises transition risks early, adjusts its investment strategy and prepares for changes in energy demand may be better positioned than one that continues to rely on the assumption that current business conditions will last indefinitely. However, a smaller estimated carbon bubble should not be mistaken for an absence of risk. The energy transition is still changing the economic outlook for fossil fuels. Some projects may become less profitable, new investments may face greater uncertainty, and assets with long operating lives may be particularly exposed if future demand or policy conditions change.
So, the key message of this research is not that fossil-fuel companies are financially safe. Significant transition risks remain, and these need to be assessed carefully. Importantly, risks will change as the stringency of carbon policies changes.
Getting the Transition Risks Right
Getting this assessment right matters. Overestimating the financial risks of the transition could create unnecessary uncertainty, discourage investment and make it harder for businesses and governments to plan. But underestimating those risks could encourage investment in projects that may become uneconomic, leaving companies, investors and financial institutions exposed to unexpected losses.
For policymakers, the findings reinforce the importance of clear and predictable climate policies. Businesses and investors need to understand the direction of policy if they are to make informed decisions about long-term investment. Sudden changes in policy can create uncertainty, while a credible and consistent policy framework gives companies greater opportunity to plan and adapt.
The findings also highlight the importance of transition planning. Rather than focusing only on the potential financial losses associated with climate action, policymakers should encourage companies to demonstrate how their investment strategies align with changing energy markets. This includes greater transparency around climate-related risks, future demand assumptions, capital expenditure and the expected economic life of fossil-fuel assets.
For investors and financial institutions, the results are a reminder to look beyond headline estimates of stranded assets. Assessing exposure requires understanding the risks facing individual companies, including their asset portfolios, financial strategies and capacity to respond to policy and market changes. Climate-related financial disclosure can help investors distinguish between companies that are preparing for the transition and those that remain heavily exposed to changing market conditions.
The Stakes for Australia’s Energy Future
These questions are particularly important for Australia, one of the world's major exporters of coal and liquefied natural gas (LNG). The value of Australia's fossil-fuel industries is closely connected to demand in international markets. Changes in energy policy, investment priorities and consumption patterns in major trading partners, including Japan, South Korea and China, could influence the long-term value of Australian coal mines, gas projects and related infrastructure. Australia therefore needs to look beyond current export revenues when making decisions about future energy investment. A project that appears commercially attractive today may face a different economic outlook over its operating life. Equally, assuming that all fossil-fuel assets will rapidly lose value could lead to decisions that overlook differences in project economics and market exposure.
For Australian policymakers, the priority should be to provide a credible and consistent direction for the energy transition, strengthen climate-related financial reporting and ensure that major investment decisions account for changing global energy markets. Governments also need to consider the broader economic consequences of this transition, including regional employment, public revenue and communities that depend on fossil-fuel industries.
The findings do not suggest that Australia can ignore the financial risks of the energy transition. Nor do they support the view that fossil-fuel industries are destined to lose their value. Instead, they point to a more practical conclusion which is the financial risks of the transition need to be understood, measured and managed, not exaggerated or dismissed. The carbon bubble debate should move beyond predictions of a sudden collapse. What matters now is whether companies, investors and governments are making decisions that reflect the energy markets of the future, rather than relying solely on the conditions of the past.
The research was conducted by Dr Mona Mashhadi Rajabi and Professor Martina Linnenluecke from UTS Business School, alongside Professor Tom Smith and Dr Jianlei Han from Macquarie Business School.
