• Posted on 18 Nov 2026

The shape of the new digital duty of care is still unknown. The Government has made one round of changes to the Bill amending the Online Safety Act while the Coalition has offered a mixed bag of responses in a motion opposing it. Meanwhile, a Senate committee is moving at a rapid pace, due to report on 20 November. After that, there’s one parliamentary sitting week left in the year.  

At this stage, there’s a vast distance between what the Government thinks is a reasonable intervention to address harmful content and what the Coalition thinks is a combination of government overreach and legislative underperformance. Not surprisingly, suggestions are coming from all directions on how the Bill could be improved. 

Long-term readers of this newsletter will know we’ve been contributing to policy debates in this area since 2020 when the previous government announced its plan to overhaul regulation and introduce a new Online Safety Act. We’ve contributed to the review of that Act and to the development of the digital duty of care. In many ways, this latest phase is the most important. As Michael explained in our submission when the Bill was introduced into Parliament late last month, there’s a critical need to move away from reactive regulatory schemes that respond to harmful content and conduct, and towards a systems-based approach which places the obligation on platforms to design safer online environments. In that last submission we said the new DDOC falls short of a fully systems-based approach because, while requiring platforms to “take appropriate action to ensure a safe online environment”, it defines that online environment by reference to an exhaustive list of online harms, thereby confining its scope.  

It doesn’t look like the Government is likely to change its mind on this. Not only is delineation of online harms integral to the design of the new regulatory framework, but pressure is coming from the other direction to trim the list of harms and avoid what is seen as government censorship. Opinions will differ on this, but one point we’ve been making for a long time is that platform censorship deserves just as much attention as government censorship. Interestingly, it’s the Coalition that said, in its motion ahead of the second reading, that “the Bill creates powerful incentives for digital platforms to censor lawful speech through penalties up to $109.2 million without accountability for wrongful removal of lawful content”.  

In our own submission, we suggested the risk of invasive monitoring by platforms and the likelihood of blocking and filtering – and of blocking and filtering more than what is necessary – needs to be considered. This can be addressed without the need for a fundamental change to the design of the Bill: the Bill could require that respect for rights, including privacy and freedom of expression, are considered when assessing whether a provider’s actions and measures to promote a safe online environment are appropriate and effective.   

That said, it’s important to recognise that even with a better upfront design that discourages unnecessary platform intervention, complaints processes need to explicitly include appeals against content moderation and other actions taken by platforms. As we’ve often said, we think government should move forward with the establishment of an external body for escalated digital platform complaints. This is something addressed in the item below by David Cazzulino and Stef Roberts-Thomson from the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman – the organisation we think is best placed to take on the functions of an external dispute resolution scheme for digital platforms. There has been a push recently by a number of civil society groups to include a private right of action in this Bill so that users can sue platforms. That’s something we support in principle, but we think access to an independent, cost-effective ombud scheme would have far more practical value for consumers. 

Finally, there’s an issue that doesn’t appear to have attracted any other attention. This Bill signals a truly lamentable development in the debate over what is recognised as “news”. Inexplicably, it includes in its categorisation of professional news material anything that “reports, investigates or explains … current issues or events of interest to persons”. This builds on the approach used in the News Media Bargaining Code and the News Bargaining Incentive, but expands the existing definition to such an extent that it renders the concept of news meaningless. The only limitation on who can deploy this definition is that they must be able to point to “rules or internal standards” that are analogous to those set out in schemes such as broadcasting codes and the Press Council principles. It’s one thing to argue that news should not be included in the content over which platforms need to exercise the digital duty of care; it’s quite another to bestow on virtually any podcaster or influencer the status of someone who commits to industry standards. And while it’s important to implement measures to promote freedom of expression, legislation that further undermines existing standards schemes is likely, in the long-term, to further pollute rather than improve the online information environment.  

So we too think there are aspects of this Bill that could be improved. But Parliament – meaning the Government, as well as the Opposition and the crossbench – really needs to find a way through the confounding array of obstacles. The collapse of this Bill would be far more consequential than the Government’s retreat on mis- and disinformation a couple of years ago, and would leave us all worse off.

Share

Author

Derek Wilding

Professor, Faculty of Law

News

Giving consumers somewhere to turn to when online services get it wrong

David Cazzulino and Stef Roberts-Thomson from the Telecommunications Industry Ombudsman explain why an independent ombudsman and a private right of action can...

News

RIP Novaya Gazeta

CMT Co-Director Monica Attard recounts the value of the Gorbachev era publication, Novaya Gazeta, and the disappointment that comes with its forced closure.

News

Frames, offence, and AI

Centre for Media Transition | From Gaza and Ukraine to France, One Nation, and Neighbours | Issue 19

News

Fog of war journalism

CMT Co-Director Monica Attard shares the CMT study of how four Australian media outlets framed the Israel–Gaza and Russia–Ukraine conflicts. The differences...