Skip to main content

Site navigation

  • University of Technology Sydney home
  • Home

    Home
  • For students

  • For industry

  • Research

Explore

  • Courses
  • Events
  • News
  • Stories
  • People

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt
  • Study at UTS

    • arrow_right_alt Find a course
    • arrow_right_alt Course areas
    • arrow_right_alt Undergraduate students
    • arrow_right_alt Postgraduate students
    • arrow_right_alt Research Masters and PhD
    • arrow_right_alt Online study and short courses
  • Student information

    • arrow_right_alt Current students
    • arrow_right_alt New UTS students
    • arrow_right_alt Graduates (Alumni)
    • arrow_right_alt High school students
    • arrow_right_alt Indigenous students
    • arrow_right_alt International students
  • Admissions

    • arrow_right_alt How to apply
    • arrow_right_alt Entry pathways
    • arrow_right_alt Eligibility
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for students

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Apply for a coursearrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt
  • Scholarshipsarrow_right_alt
  • Featured industries

    • arrow_right_alt Agriculture and food
    • arrow_right_alt Defence and space
    • arrow_right_alt Energy and transport
    • arrow_right_alt Government and policy
    • arrow_right_alt Health and medical
    • arrow_right_alt Corporate training
  • Explore

    • arrow_right_alt Tech Central
    • arrow_right_alt Case studies
    • arrow_right_alt Research
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for industry

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Find a UTS expertarrow_right_alt
  • Partner with usarrow_right_alt
  • Explore

    • arrow_right_alt Explore our research
    • arrow_right_alt Research centres and institutes
    • arrow_right_alt Graduate research
    • arrow_right_alt Research partnerships
arrow_right_altVisit our hub for research

For you

  • Libraryarrow_right_alt
  • Staffarrow_right_alt
  • Alumniarrow_right_alt
  • Current studentsarrow_right_alt

POPULAR LINKS

  • Find a UTS expertarrow_right_alt
  • Research centres and institutesarrow_right_alt
  • University of Technology Sydney home
Explore the University of Technology Sydney
Category Filters:
University of Technology Sydney home University of Technology Sydney home
  1. home
  2. arrow_forward_ios ... Newsroom
  3. arrow_forward_ios ... 2023
  4. arrow_forward_ios 06
  5. arrow_forward_ios Journalists: caution advised

Journalists: caution advised

16 June 2023
Scales of Justice with criminal sitting on one side leg chained to ball balanced in other

The dismissal of Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation suits against several Australian news outlets has understandably brought a sense of vindication to much of the Australian media, as well as speculation on what will come next. Justice Anthony Besanko upheld the defendants’ claims that the defamatory imputations in their investigative reporting were, in the majority, substantially true. These included that Roberts-Smith murdered and ordered the murder of prisoners, thus committing war crimes.

This raises a question about how the media should describe the verdict, and indeed, Roberts-Smith himself. There appears to be a consensus that the verdict means it is legitimate to call him a murderer and a war criminal. In one sense, this seems right: the judge found the imputations to be substantially true, and the media can thereby republish those claims without fear of further defamation.

As much of the reporting has also observed, there is a difference between what will pass muster in a civil case – namely, the balance of probabilities – and the lack of reasonable doubt that is required to prove criminal charges. The difference is brought to the fore when we consider what might happen if criminal charges are laid against Roberts-Smith, and he is acquitted. Could we then continue to legitimately call him a murderer and a war criminal? It seems not, yet the civil verdict would remain unaffected by the outcome of the criminal trial.

There is a subtle difference between coverage of the verdict and the original reports that were the subject of the trial. The latter generally used the language of allegation, while the language of recent reporting, particularly in headlines, has been less qualified, even categorical. This seems a mistake, even if only because it precludes the nuance that may be needed later. Just as Justice Besanko qualified his own findings with a lengthy discussion of the civil standard of proof and the procedures for weighing evidence, it would seem judicious for journalists to qualify their claims. This might mean more than just referring to the civil standard in reporting the judge’s verdict, but instead conveying a sense of probability or likelihood appropriate to findings established on that standard. Consider what ‘the balance of probabilities’ means, and proceed on that basis.

Picture of Michael Davis

Michael Davis, CMT Research Fellow

 

This article is from our fortnightly newsletter published on 16 June 2023. 

To read the newsletter in full, click here. Subscribe here.

Share
Share this on Facebook Share this on Twitter Share this on LinkedIn
Back to CMT news

Acknowledgement of Country

UTS acknowledges the Gadigal People of the Eora Nation and the Boorooberongal People of the Dharug Nation upon whose ancestral lands our campuses now stand. We would also like to pay respect to the Elders both past and present, acknowledging them as the traditional custodians of knowledge for these lands. 

University of Technology Sydney

City Campus

15 Broadway, Ultimo, NSW 2007

Get in touch with UTS

Follow us

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Facebook

A member of

  • Australian Technology Network
Use arrow keys to navigate within each column of links. Press Tab to move between columns.

Study

  • Find a course
  • Undergraduate
  • Postgraduate
  • How to apply
  • Scholarships and prizes
  • International students
  • Campus maps
  • Accommodation

Engage

  • Find an expert
  • Industry
  • News
  • Events
  • Experience UTS
  • Research
  • Stories
  • Alumni

About

  • Who we are
  • Faculties
  • Learning and teaching
  • Sustainability
  • Initiatives
  • Equity, diversity and inclusion
  • Campus and locations
  • Awards and rankings
  • UTS governance

Staff and students

  • Current students
  • Help and support
  • Library
  • Policies
  • StaffConnect
  • Working at UTS
  • UTS Handbook
  • Contact us
  • Copyright © 2025
  • ABN: 77 257 686 961
  • CRICOS provider number: 00099F
  • TEQSA provider number: PRV12060
  • TEQSA category: Australian University
  • Privacy
  • Copyright
  • Disclaimer
  • Accessibility